Seeing is believing

Cars are getting safer. We know that from the results of Euro NCAP crash tests.

But what about ‘real world’ experience on the road? Are the broad roof pillars demanded by crash safety (and indeed the swoopy styling dictated by fashion) making modern cars harder to see out of?

Consumer group Which? reckons so – and has published a list of the worst offenders.




Microsoft and partners may be compensated if you purchase something through recommended links in this article.

How Which tests visibility

For every car tested, Which? uses a camera mounted at driver’s head height and rotated through 360 degrees. This measures all-round vision and how much it is impaired by windscreen pillars, headrests and so on.

Other factors, such as the brightness of the headlights and availability of a rear-view camera, are taken into account, then each vehicle is given a rating.

All the cars featured here scored just two stars out of five for visibility.




Microsoft and partners may be compensated if you purchase something through recommended links in this article.

Chevrolet Camaro: 2015-2018

We’d hope this all-American muscle car has poor visibility because of all the tyre smoke in its mirrors. In reality, though, it’s largely due to those shallow side windows and Coke-bottle hips.




Microsoft and partners may be compensated if you purchase something through recommended links in this article.

Chevrolet Cruze: 2009-2015

A very different Chevrolet, the instantly forgettable Cruze was a budget-priced rival for the Skoda Octavia. Nope, we’ve no idea what’s going on here either…




Microsoft and partners may be compensated if you purchase something through recommended links in this article.

Chevrolet Orlando: 2011-2015

Perhaps by choosing the name ‘Orlando’, Chevrolet hoped to conjure images of sunshine and family fun. Its people carrier is well suited to families, but losing your luggage at Heathrow is frankly more fun.




Microsoft and partners may be compensated if you purchase something through recommended links in this article.

Citroen Dispatch Combi: 2007-2015

Yes, it’s a van with windows. And visibility is – one assumes – better than the actual Citroen Dispatch van. Unfortunately, wide pillars and bulky headrests lumber the Combi with a two-star rating.




Microsoft and partners may be compensated if you purchase something through recommended links in this article.

Citroen Spacetourer: 2016-on

The huge Spacetourer can carry up to nine people, or you can have five seats and a gigantic boot. Those tinted rear windows might keep your passengers cool, but they don’t help the already poor visibility.




Microsoft and partners may be compensated if you purchase something through recommended links in this article.

Dacia Duster: 2018-on

‘You do the maths’ says ‘Finchy’ from The Office on those Dacia adverts. Well, Which? has done the maths, and the Duster comes up short. ‘Reversing around a corner in the current Dacia Duster, which anybody taking their driving test before December 2017 may have been tested on, would be particularly tricky,’ said the consumer group.




Microsoft and partners may be compensated if you purchase something through recommended links in this article.

Dacia Duster: 2013-2018

That also applies to the previous-generation Duster, launched in 2013, which looks scarcely different to the current car. Still, owners seem to like them.




Microsoft and partners may be compensated if you purchase something through recommended links in this article.

Dacia Sandero: 2013-on

Britain’s cheapest new car starts from £6,995. It’s entirely unsuitable for driving up the hill at Goodwood Festival of Speed, as pictured here.




Microsoft and partners may be compensated if you purchase something through recommended links in this article.

Ford Ecosport: 2014-on

The Ecosport was a bit mediocre, let’s be honest. A Fiesta-based crossover originally designed for markets such as Brazil, it disappointed in many areas – including visibility.




Microsoft and partners may be compensated if you purchase something through recommended links in this article.

Ford Ka Plus: 2016-2019

Another Ford that missed the mark, the short-lived Ka+ was roomy but dull. Essentially a Ka with five doors, it locked horns (somewhat timidly) with the Dacia Sandero.




Microsoft and partners may be compensated if you purchase something through recommended links in this article.

Ford Ka Plus Active: 2018-2019

Having delivered the world a Ka with more doors, Ford then served up a pseudo-SUV version. “Monsieur, with these small cars you’re really spoiling us.”




Microsoft and partners may be compensated if you purchase something through recommended links in this article.

Honda Civic: 2006-2011

The eighth-generation Honda Civic still looks space-age, with design features such as hidden rear door handles and triangular tailpipes. Its horizontally split rear window does visibility no favours, though.




Microsoft and partners may be compensated if you purchase something through recommended links in this article.

Honda CR-Z: 2010-2013

The quirky hybrid CR-Z also adopted a split window design. The upper section of glass was mostly for letting light in, with a narrow (and heavily tinted) slot for rearward vision.




Microsoft and partners may be compensated if you purchase something through recommended links in this article.

Jeep Wrangler: 2007-2018

Like the original Land Rover Defender, the Wrangler appeals despite its obvious shortcomings. Those huge headrests can’t help visibility, though. Like the other cars here, the Jeep earns just two stars.




Microsoft and partners may be compensated if you purchase something through recommended links in this article.

Kia Rio: 2005-2011

We suspect the biggest danger when driving a 2005-2011 Kia Rio is falling asleep at the wheel. The Korean supermini shared its platform with the Hyundai Accent and… zzzzz. Sorry, where were we?




Microsoft and partners may be compensated if you purchase something through recommended links in this article.

Mercedes-Benz GLC Coupe: 2016-on

Ah, the noble SUV coupe. More weight, greater fuel consumption and inferior handling to a ‘normal’ coupe, along with less space and a higher price than an equivalent SUV. What’s not to like? Oh, the poor visibility.




Microsoft and partners may be compensated if you purchase something through recommended links in this article.

Nissan 370Z: 2009-on

Amazingly, the Nissan 370Z has been on sale for 11 years. Its slash-cut styling is distinctive and the 3.7-litre V6 provides plenty of oomph. But just buy a used Porsche Cayman.




Microsoft and partners may be compensated if you purchase something through recommended links in this article.

Nissan Micra: 2017-on

Earlier versions of the Micra were beloved of driving schools. One wonders if that’s the case now. Which? said the Micra’s narrow rear window provides an ‘almost visor-like rear view of the road’.




Microsoft and partners may be compensated if you purchase something through recommended links in this article.

Renault Fluence: 2012-2013

Apparently, Renault’s plan with the Fluence ZE was to make electric cars so terminally boring that people bought Meganes and Clios instead. It kind of worked. The combustion-engined Fluence lives on in Asia, South America and elsewhere.




Microsoft and partners may be compensated if you purchase something through recommended links in this article.

Renault Megane: 2016-on

The current Megane is the most striking C-segment hatchback. The price you pay for that wedgy profile and shallow glass, though, is two-star visibility.




Microsoft and partners may be compensated if you purchase something through recommended links in this article.

Renault Megane Coupe: 2009-2016

More of a three-door hatchback than a true coupe, the Megane boasted an upswept rear side window and near-horizontal tailgate glass. Good for style, but hardly practical.




Microsoft and partners may be compensated if you purchase something through recommended links in this article.

Renault Wind: 2010-2012

Its dodgy name surely didn’t help sales, nor did the Wind’s oddball styling. Flying buttresses and the mechanism for its rotating metal roof make rearward visibility seem an afterthought.




Microsoft and partners may be compensated if you purchase something through recommended links in this article.

Smart EQ Fortwo: 2018-on

The Smart was built for dodging through city traffic, so you’d hope for good all-round vision. Not so. The electric EQ Fortwo is worse than many large cars in this regard.




Microsoft and partners may be compensated if you purchase something through recommended links in this article.

Smart Fortwo Cabriolet: 2016-2019

The same goes for the Fortwo Cabriolet. Unless you’re looking directly upwards, visibility is rather limited. It also resembles an oversized shoe.




Microsoft and partners may be compensated if you purchase something through recommended links in this article.

Toyota iQ: 2008-2014

Most famous for spawning the Aston Martin Cygnet, the Toyota iQ was a clever and underrated city car. Those chunky rear pillars don’t help when parking, however.




Microsoft and partners may be compensated if you purchase something through recommended links in this article.

Vauxhall Vivaro Life: 2019-on

If someone tells you to “get a life”, they probably don’t mean a Vauxhall Vivaro Life. Buying this oversized MPV is truly a head-over-heart decision. It would make a good airport taxi.




Microsoft and partners may be compensated if you purchase something through recommended links in this article.

Volkswagen Jetta: 2006-2011

Volkswagen hardly sold any Jetta saloons in the UK – and for good reason. The closely related Golf hatchback is better looking, more practical and easier to see out of. Why bother?




Microsoft and partners may be compensated if you purchase something through recommended links in this article.


29/29 SLIDES