Why Gandalf The White Is More Powerful Than The Grey

Gandalf the White is clearly more powerful than Gandalf the Grey in Lord of the Rings, but where does that extra boost of magic come from?

Why is Gandalf the White more powerful than Gandalf the Grey in The Lord of the Rings? When Frodo Baggins and the Fellowship of the Ring watch their funny old bearded Shire-botherer fall to his death in the Mines of Moria, none expect to see Gandalf again. One must never underestimate a wizard, however, and Gandalf returns one film/book later in The Two Towers. Before his tussle with the Balrog, the wizard’s official title was Gandalf the Grey, but upon announcing his return in the dank, green surrounds of Fangorn Forest, Ian McKellen’s character identifies himself as Gandalf the White.

The Lord of the Rings (both J.R.R. Tolkien’s original novels and Peter Jackson’s movie trilogy) keeps the full extent of Gandalf’s powers deliberately obscured, before and after his grand return. Nevertheless, it’s evident Gandalf the White is the more formidable. Both Gandalf iterations deploy mostly flame and light magic in The Lord of the Rings, with Gandalf the Grey depicted illuminating darkened paths, conjuring fires, and emanating brilliant white light that knocks back enemies. Gandalf the White carries considerably more wisdom and authority than Gandalf the Grey, and his magical prowess expands as a result. His second incarnation shatters Saruman’s staff effortlessly, fends off the Witch-king of Angmar, and relinquishes Théoden from his rival’s control. As Tolkien himself writes, “His wisdom and power are much greater… the old Gandalf could not have dealt so with Théoden, nor with Saruman.“

Related: Amazon’s Lord Of The Rings Can Fix One Key Mistake From Original Trilogy

To understand Gandalf the White’s higher power, one must first consider where the wizards came from, and their purpose visiting Middle-earth. The Lord of the Rings‘ five wizards were originally angelic Maiar from the Undying Lands across the sea. Gandalf’s Maia form was known as Olórin, and vastly eclipsed Gandalf the Grey and Gandalf the White in potency, wisdom, and will. These five Maiar were sent to Middle-earth by the Valar (archangels of Tolkien’s lore), but incarnated in mortal bodies and forbidden from utilizing the full extent of their divine might. When Gandalf recalls his former life during The Lord of the Rings, his memories seem somewhat hazy – as if his years as Olórin are somehow distanced. The five wizard messengers were each assigned ranks, with Saruman the White their chief, and Gandalf the Grey somewhere underneath (likely second) in that hierarchy.

By the time Gandalf the Grey died fighting the Balrog in The Fellowship of the Ring, Saruman had long abandoned the task appointed to him by the Valar, and a new leader for the wizards of Middle-earth was required. Thus, the fallen Gandalf was brought back from the void by Eru – the God of Tolkien’s mythology – and given a promotion to Gandalf the White. Along with dressing like he just found a better brand of washing powder, Gandalf the White is permitted access to more of his Maia abilities. Therefore, the upgrade between Gandalfs isn’t so much an evolution, but a partial unveiling of the strength he once possessed as Olórin.

According to Tolkien’s published letters, the purpose of having a powerful “White” rank among Middle-earth’s wizards was as a more direct, “emergency” force against Sauron. None of the wizards – even their leader – were allowed to dominate the peoples of Middle-earth, nor go Maia-to-Maia versus the fiery eye in the sky. Instead, they were supposed to lead, encourage, and advise Middle-earth’s population. The White wizard, however, was permitted to take a stronger stance than his magical pals, should Sauron’s advance become too great. For this reason, it was imperative Gandalf the White be more powerful than Gandalf the Grey.

Without that added strength, Rohan would’ve aligned with Saruman, who in turn would’ve attempted overthrowing Sauron. Minas Tirith likely would’ve fallen before the king could even return, and the Dark Lord’s eye wouldn’t have been drawn away from Frodo and Sam, allowing Sauron to reclaim the One Ring, complete his resurrection, and dominate whatever remained of Middle-earth. Good job, then, that Gandalf the White was a vast improvement upon his predecessor in The Lord of the Rings.

More: LOTR Secretly Revealed Why White Walkers Weren’t Game of Thrones’ End Villain

Andrew Garfield Reveals Only People He Felt Bad Lying About No Way Home To

About The Author